Carmella's Pizzaria

Reviews about Carmella's Pizzaria

• 2 / 5

  By Amy Atwood
  Expensive, slow, poor quality. Stopped in lunchtime on a Saturday. Spent ~$40 for 2 Italian grinders, a chef salad ($10.50 for the salad alone), 2 sodas, 2 chips. The chef salad had lettuce "pieces" torn it looked like (not cut by a knife) & some pieces -like in my photo posted here- were the size of my hand, no joke. There was turkey and ham lunch meat (low-grade, salty) sliced in thin strips along with the worst I've ever tasted processed white cheese (sliced in thin strips as well). I love American cheese but this was some pretty low-grade stuff. The bathrooms dirty, ceiling tiles stained throughout. The cashier was very pleasant, though so I think it's a matter of them getting their food up to par and re-looking at what they charge for it. Could not believe that cost us over $40.
  December 07, 2016
• 4 / 5

  By Mark Dalton
  Best pizza on the island. Expensive though.
  June 02, 2016